The Alan Review
Editors:
Wendy Glenn, Senior Editor
Ricki Ginsberg, Assistant Editor
Danielle King, Assistant Editor
thealanreview@gmail.com
Volume 41, Number 1
Fall 2013


DLA Ejournal Home | ALAN Home | Table of Contents for this issue | Search ALAN and other ejournals

https://doi.org/10.21061/alan.v41i1.a.6
Lawrence Baines and Jane Fisher

From Cave Art to Cryonics

A quick scan of the books that students carry around in school reveals a plethora of young adult (YA) fantasy and science fiction titles. Insurgent ( Roth, 2012 ), The Scorch Trials (Dashner, 2011), and The Rise of Nine ( Lore, 2012 ) seem to be current favorites. However, some students just do not enjoy science fiction, despite the popularity of books such as Matched ( Condie, 2011 ) and Hunger Games ( Collins, 2010 ), and the seemingly endless sagas of vampires and wizards. Some students simply prefer to read nonfiction, especially the kind of “true stories” that make them gasp and ask, “Is that really true?”

The good news is that the number of quality, nonfiction books for students is burgeoning. No matter the topic, from cave art to cryonics, a universe of new titles has the potential to invigorate the classroom with fresh perspectives. As with literary fiction, a primary criterion for the selection of nonfiction texts is the quality of the writing. In our classrooms, we like to integrate YA nonfiction with contemporary trade books, selected online articles, videos, news stories, websites, and as much relevant art, music, and sensory stimuli as we can find. Routinely using sensory stimuli (usually from the Internet) in conjunction with print nonfiction encourages students to move from reading to understanding, and at the teacher’s discretion, to research and creative projects.

Pondering the Future

Several recent YA dystopian novels postulate about the ways that innovations in microbiology could go awry. For example, in Wither ( DeStefano, 2011 ), scientists who are trying to eradicate disease accidentally program a shorter lifespan into the DNA of humans so that women die at age 20 and men die at age 25. In Pretties ( Westerfeld, 2010 ), characters pop pills to remain perpetually beautiful and “bubbly.” It is a dose of tracker jacker venom that convinces Peeta that assassinating Katniss is the right thing to do in Mockingjay ( Collins, 2011 ). While such speculations about trends in microbiology may seem bizarre, they are no more incredible than actual developments, which include tiny brain implants that dramatically increase intelligence and nanoparticles that, once injected into the bloodstream, detect and cure human disease at the cellular level before it starts.

These developments, along with hundreds of others (including spacecraft crafted to the size of a sewing needle) are featured in Physics of the Future ( Kaku, 2011a ). Recently, when I brought a two-page excerpt from Kaku’s book, entitled “Life in 2100” ( Kaku, 2011b ), that proclaimed that “the Internet will be in your contact lens,” “cars will be driverless,” and “the robot industry will dwarf the size of the current automobile industry” (pp. 45–46) to an eighth–grade English class, students actually attempted to pry the article out of my hands so that they could read it. The article also generated enthusiasm among students in a twelfth-grade Advanced Placement class. In the AP class, one student commented that he hoped a driverless car would improve the road habits of elderly drivers; another student predicted that school administrators would likely prohibit Internet-ready contact lenses, as they had already banned cellphones.

While it can be useful to pair YA literature with YA and adult nonfiction with similar themes ( Walther & Fuhler, 2008 ), the oeuvre of nonfiction is sufficiently ly compelling to constitute a worthwhile area of study all its own. Researchers interested in student engagement have long established that students are more likely to read when topics are related to their own lives ( Gambrell, 2011 ; Guthrie, Wigfield, Metsala, & Cox, 1999 ; Wang & Holcombe, 2010 ). Perhaps nothing is more relevant to the lives of adolescents than the future and their prospective place in it, so we built a unit around an exploration of the future.

Futurist and inventor Kurzweil has written several books ( 2005 , 2012 ) and created a website as a forum for discussing the future. The KurzweilAI website ( www.kurzweilai.net ) brims with free articles, books, and videos. The Web address of the site combines inventor Kurzweil’s last name with AI or “artificial intelligence,” though the site says that AI stands for “accelerating intelligence.” Recent offerings include stories about a robot programmed to clean and tidy up, a forthcoming manned flight to Mars in 2033, the benefits and liabilities of a swarm of artillery-enhanced drones, and three-dimensional avatars (one is Princess Leia from Star Wars ) who are soon going to greet tourists in New York City airports.

Kurzweil is famous for making outlandish predictions about the future, so an initial reaction to his website might be a roll of the eyes. However, for those who bother to track his predictions, Kurzweil’s record is quite impressive ( Kurzweil, 2013 ). In fact, in a 148-page update on the accuracy of his predictions, he writes,

I made 147 predictions for 2009 in ASM [the book Age of Spiritual Machines ], which I wrote in the 1990s. Of these, 115 (78 percent) are entirely correct as of the end of 2009, and another 12 (8 percent) are “essentially correct” —a total of 127 predictions (86 percent) are correct or essentially correct. Another 17 (12 percent) are partially correct, and 3 (2 percent) are wrong.

Kurzweil is also famous for saying that the individual who will live to be 150 years old is alive today. He confesses that he is trying to stay alive as long as possible because he believes that, relatively soon, new breakthroughs in science will permit humans to live a high-quality life for hundreds of years without the hindrances commonly associated with old age. Indeed, the title of one of his books is Fantastic Voyage: Live Long Enough to Live Forever ( Kurzweil & Grossman, 2005 ). According to Kurzweil, if consciousness, personality, and brains could be downloaded, then they could become operable in robots. At the point where humans and machines merge, immortality becomes plausible.

Perhaps nothing is more relevant to the lives of adolescents than the future and their prospective place in it.

In the book Ending Aging (2005), De Grey notes that aging is often the result of mutations of cells. As cells mutate or die, the body begins to shut down. De Grey asserts that by inhibiting cell mutation, a human could live much longer, perhaps to the age of 1000 years old. De Grey has an interesting talk on TED ( De Grey, 2012 ) and articles and videos of his speeches and presentations abound on the Internet.

An organization called the Methuselah Foundation, founded by De Grey, has as its mission “to significantly extend the healthy lifespan of humanity.” The organization’s website ( methuselahfoundation.org ) describes several initiatives, including information about a prize established for the first company that regenerates a complete human organ ( Methuselah Foundation, 2012 ). Also, there is the SENS (Strategies for Engineered Negligible Senescence) Foundation, a clearinghouse on breakthroughs on aging, which lists De Grey as one of its chief scientists ( SENS, 2012 ).

Among the most radical of organizations related to aging is Alcor, a corporation that will freeze you through a process called cryonics, with the promise that you may be revived at some point in the future, preferably after the cure for aging has been discovered. While cryonics might seem outlandish or improbable, as of May 31, 2012, Alcor had 968 members and 111 patients ( Alcor, 2013 ). A patient is an individual who has paid the $200,000+ membership fee for full body cryopreservation or $80,000+ for neurocryopreservation (just the brain). A member has paid an initiation fee and a number of additional fees in the hope of finding enough cash to pay for the preservation process at some point before Judgment Day. Alcor also features a free, slick magazine that is well worth reading.

The premise of cryonics has emerged in recent YA fiction, such as Across the Universe ( Revis, 2011 ). Delving into real, science-based speculations about the future can be enlivening for students who might not be big literature-lovers. Learning about transformative technologies that could dramatically impact the future is a way of giving students a sense of time and place in the midst of tumultuous change.

How Long Will You Live?

An interesting way to begin the How Long Will You Live? project is to show how a person’s physical features change with time. A photographer from Argentina has a nice website that shows photos of his family over several years ( Goldberg, 2012 ).

Ask students to write down three facts from each of these websites:

The How Long Will You Live? project requires students to combine readings of Kurzweil and De Grey with knowledge of the claims of Alcor and current data about longevity. The activity in Figure 1 requires students to answer three questions that require critical thinking, close reading, and considerable creativity. For the first question, students turn a table into a graph and make a prediction about trends in aging. The second question requires students to try to understand differences in the average lifespans in various countries. Possible reasons for a longer life include diet, lack of wars, and availability and quality of medical care. The third question asks students to write a story as if they were much older—30, 50, 80, or 100 years old. The idea is for students to work in details about daily life in the future based upon their previous readings. If students need inspiration for what their daily life might be like, the free Corning video available online might help ( Corning, 2013 ).

Immortality is a theme in many Norse and Greek ancient myths, an obsession with the Romantic poets, and it shows up frequently in novels such as The Picture of Dorian Grey ( Wilde, 2013 ), Tuck Everlasting ( Babbitt, 1975 ), and current dystopian YA literature, such as Incarceron ( Fisher, 2011 ), The Postmortal ( Magary, 2011 ), and The Declaration ( Malley, 2008 ). These fictional works should prove especially engaging to students after perusing the landscape of the factual future-in-progress.

Every Bone Tells a Story

Before Ancient Greece, and perhaps even before the development of language itself, there was art. Mithen (2005) , in his provocative book The Singing Neanderthals , posits that singing, dancing (of a sort), and art actually preceded language. Anyone who has seen primitive “cave art,” or at least Herzog’s documentary film Cave of Forgotten Dreams ( Nelson & Ciuffo, 2010 ), knows the power of the image to communicate across thousands of years. A discussion of cave art appears in the pages of the entertaining and sometimes irreverent Every Bone Tells a Story ( Rubalcaba and Robertshaw, 2010 ), a finalist for the YALSA nonfiction award in 2011. Every Bone is the account of four ancient hominins—Turkana Boy, Kennewick Man, Otzi the Iceman, and Lapedo Child—who, by the power of the mysterious trail of history, left behind their fossilized remains. Containing encyclopedic-grade information, this text is written for students in a way that is both accessible and intriguing. In essence, students walk in the shoes of a scientist, archaeologist, adventurer, and artist, examining artifacts from characters who died millions of years ago.

Archaeologists debate whether or not Turkana Boy had the ability to speak and use language while he was alive. While it was finally deduced that no, he did not use language, the subject of art as symbolic expression and a form of language arose among anthropologists. Students who are drawn into discussions of “What ifs” will be deeply interested in how characters like Turkana Boy used art to communicate.

In reference to the cave art found at archaeological sites, Rubalcaba and Robertshaw write, “Cave art has some of the most mysterious examples of symbolic art. There are rows of dots, zigzags, V shapes, and grids. What do they mean?” (2010, p. 35). Students

1. Look at the table below on US Life Expectancy. Draw a graph of the average lifespan of Americans from 1900–2100 using intervals of 20 years (1900, 1920 . . . 2080, 2100). Data is available to 2020, but you will have to predict American life expectancies for 2020–2100. What are the trends? Write a rationale for your prediction.

US Life Expectancy at Birth, by Sex, in Selected Years (in years)
Year Average Age Males Females
1900-1902 49.2 47.9 50.7
1909-1911 51.5 49.9 53.2
1919-1921 56.4 55.5 57.4
1929-1931 59.2 57.7 60.9
1939-1941 63.3 61.6 65.9
1949-1951 68.1 65.5 71.0
1959-1961 69.9 66.8 73.2
1969-1971 70.8 67.0 74.6
1979-1981 73.9 70.01 77.6
1989-1991 75.4 71.8 78.8
2003 77.5 74.8 80.1
2015 (predicted) 78.9 76.4 81.4
2020 (predicted) 79.5 77.1 81.9
2050 ? ? ?
2100 ? ? ?
Data gathered from Shrestha (2006) and US Census Bureau (2012) .

2. Compare life expectancies among three different countries. Write a summary of the differences in life expectancies and comment on why you think these differences exist.

Rank (of 221 countries) Country Average lifespan (rounded)
1 Monaco 90
3 Japan 84
12 Canada 81
28 Germany 80
30 United Kingdom 80
50 United States 78
95 China 75
144 Iraq 71
199 Congo 55
221 chad 49

3. Assume that Kurzweil is correct and that people will live to be 150. Watch the video about the future at http://www.corning.com/news_center/videos/ADayMadeofGlass2.aspx ( Corning, 2013 ). Imagine that you are one of these ages:
30 50 80 100. Tell a story about a typical day in your life.

Evaluation:
20 points=Details (Specifics about the future are interesting and seem plausible, based upon your reading, current trends.)
40 points=Quality (Story starts in the midst of you doing something. Tell your story so that the realities of the future are revealed. Include an ending.)
20 points=Smooth transitions and good organization
20 points=Technique, grammar, mechanics, word choice

Figure 1. How long will you live?

can ponder the same question: what is the intention behind ancient cave art?

A free, online article ( Thompson, 2013 ) reveals that thousands of “flutings” were made by children’s fingers in the soft clay walls in French caverns over 13,000 years ago. The finger marks range from straight lines to “hectiforms”—hut-shaped symbols. The discovery gives credence to the theory that children were frequently contributors to the galleries of cave art that continue to be uncovered. Pertinent questions to ask students might include:

  1. Were children taught to draw these lines and symbols, or were they a natural instinct?
  2. Why aren’t the drawings more detailed?

The Bradshaw Foundation (2013) is a rich source of cave art from all over the world. Although the cave art discussed in the flutings article did not incorporate traditional artistic components, such as the use of color, many cave drawings featured on The Bradshaw Foundation’s website are incredibly colorful.

Of course, symbols are important in cave art just as they are in everyday life. Ask students about contemporary symbols used to designate no smoking, the girl’s bathroom, disabled parking, and other areas. Indeed, an important job of the anthropologist is determining the meaning of found symbols.

Symbolism and Critical Thinking

After viewing a variety of cave art, ask students to imagine themselves as ancient cave painters. What drawings would they create? What message would the drawings communicate? Choose a compelling image from the Bradshaw Foundation website to discuss as a class and pose the following questions:

Have students select a different cave drawing and try to discern possible meanings. Ask them to put themselves in the place of an ancient cave painter— what story or sentiment did they want to tell? Have students think of a story and then use a series of only three symbols to represent it. Encourage students to use simple symbols, but to make the message clear. For example, someone who wants to communicate, “It’s cold outside of our dwelling. We need to build a fire,” might use the three, simple symbols in Figure 2.

A useful reference for how symbols work is Picture This!, a book that tells the story of Little Red Riding Hood through a series of simple shapes ( Bang, 2000 ). Once students create symbol stories, the series of symbols are presented to the rest of the class. Students attempt to guess the story behind the symbols.

Cave Art Example
Figure 2. Using simple symbols to tell a story can help students ponder the use of symbols in cave art and other contexts.

The student (or group) that interprets the symbols correctly (matching the story) should be declared the champion story storyteller.

What Is Your Story?

The stories of Turkana Boy, Lapedo Child, Kennewick Man, and Otzi the Iceman are deeply engaging, and students tend to connect to these characters as strongly as they might to a favorite fictional character. It helps that the fossilized remains of these individuals are portrayed in great photographic detail throughout Every Bone Tells a Story . The ways that archaeologists can piece together stories from scraps of evidence are remarkable. Rubalcaba and Robertshaw note, “Most people think the dead are silent, but to an archaeologist they’re boisterous storytellers. . . . Of course the dead don’t leap out of their graves and give away their secrets. It takes scientists from every field imaginable to coax the details out of them” (2010, p. 1).

Ask students to consider what kind of story they would tell if they were discovered thousands of years into the future, as marvelous treasures, to scientists who studied their artifacts and bones. Would scientists be able to tell if they were an excellent athlete or an avid reader? Perhaps a soccer player might have sustained a shin injury that left tell-tale marks on his bones. Or maybe a fashionista’s bones would be found along with gems and jewelry.

The last pages of Every Bone describe “Iceman” Otzi (pp. 125–162). Found with Otzi was a 5,300-yearold ax, a quiver of arrows, straw-stuffed shoes, clothes, and a backpack ( Ives, 2003 ; Ker, 2011 ). Ask students to make a list of things that, if they were to be preserved for the rest of time, they would likely have with them. What would the artifacts reveal about their hobbies and interests?

After lists have been made and you notice eyes wandering to neighboring lists, ask students to share artifacts and write lists on the board so that the entire class can see the diverse types of objects archaeologists might find. If someone put “boots” on their list, for example, what are some inferences about that person that an archaeologist might make?

Finally, ask students to pretend that their fossilized remains have been found, surrounded by their ancient possessions, by an archaeologist. In a narrative report, ask students to write about themselves from the point of view of the archeologist who discovered them. Reports should include:

  1. The location of the discovery
  2. The situation of the bones (Were the bones scattered or intact? Was the skeleton laying down/jumping?)
  3. What artifacts were found with the bones, and what can the archaeologist deduce from the artifacts? (Does a bicycle helmet on the skull say that the student rode a bike or that they had a weird fashion sense?)
  4. The tone should be appropriate for the narrator— excited, irritated, elated, or confused—depending on the type of person that the narrator might be. The tone should be communicated in word choice as well as in the oral delivery, as reports are read aloud.

Encourage students to be creative in their “findings.” The anthropological reports in Every Bone Tells a Story provide students with professional, real-life models (pp. 53, 108) for their report writing.

Conclusion

Most teachers still associate symbolism, inference, and characterization with fiction. However, these literary elements can be readily applied to nonfiction texts as well. “Good nonfiction books are as rich in possibilities for deep, thoughtful discussion as any good novel” ( Sullivan, 2001, p. 45 ). The edict that teachers should integrate more nonfiction texts into instruction, plan for more multimedia interactions, assign more research projects, and tackle more challenging texts will require a re-thinking of the traditional curriculum, not only in English, but also in social studies, science, and even mathematics ( Common Core State Standards Initiative, 2013 ). From cave art to cryonics, nonfiction offers compelling opportunities for students to read new stories, to make new connections, and to build their knowledge in new ways ( Common Core Literature, 2013 ).

Lawrence Baines is Associate Dean of Research and Graduate Studies at the University of Oklahoma. Parts of this article were drawn from his coauthored new book Teaching Challenging Texts (2013), published by Rowman & Littlefield. Lawrence’s websites include www.lawrence baines.com , www.commoncoreliterature.com , and www .teacherquality.info . His email is lbaines@ou.edu .

Jane Fisher teaches eighth-grade language arts at Whittier Middle School in Norman, Oklahoma. Jane is coauthor of Teaching Challenging Texts (2013) and is currently working on a manuscript titled Nonfiction as Exploration. Her email is jfish416@ou.edu .

References

Alcor. (2013). Cryonics. Retrieved from http://www.alcor.org/ magazine.

Babbit, N. (1975). Tuck everlasting . New York, NY: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

Bang, M. (2000). Picture this! San Francisco, CA: Chronicle Books.

Bradshaw Foundation. (2013). Bradshaw Foundation website http://bradshawfoundation.com.

Cashore, K. (2009). Graceling. Orlando, FL: Harcourt.

Center for Disease Control. (2012, January). National vital statistics report for January 2012 . Retrieved from www.cdc.gov/ nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr60/nvsr60_04.pdf .

Collins, S. (2011). Mockingjay . New York, NY: Scholastic.

Collins, S. (2010). The Hunger games . New York, NY: Scholastic.

Common Core State Standards Initiative. (2013). Implementing the common core state standards . Retrieved from http:// www.corestandards.org/ .

Common Core Literature. (2013). Teaching challenging texts . Retrieved from www.commoncoreliterature.com .

Condie, A. (2011). Matched . New York, NY: Dutton.

Corning. (2013). A day made of glass 2 . Video retrieved from http://www.corning.com/news_center/videos/ADayMade ofGlass2.aspx .

Dashner, J. (2011). The scorch trials . New York, NY: Ember.

De Grey, A. (2005). Ending aging . New York, NY: St. Martin’s Press.

De Grey, A. (2012). Defying aging. Retrieved from www.ted .com/speakers/aubrey_de_grey.html .

DeStefano, L. (2011). Wither . New York, NY: Simon & Schuster.

Fisher, C. (2011). Incarceron . New York, NY: Penguin.

Gambrell, L. B. (2011). Seven rules of engagement: What’s most important to know about motivation to read. Reading Teacher , 65, 172–178.

Goldberg, D. (2012). Photos of the Goldbergs over time. Retrieved from www.zonezero.com .

Guthrie, J. T., Wigfield, A., Metsala, J. L., & Cox, K. E. (1999). Motivational and cognitive predictors of text comprehension and reading amount. Scientific Studies of Reading, 3, , 231–256.

Ives, S. (2003). Was ancient Alpine “Iceman” killed in battle? Retrieved from http://news.nationalgeographic.com/ news/2003/10/1030_031030_icemandeath.html .

Kaku, M. (2011a). Physics of the future . New York, NY: Doubleday.

Kaku, M. (2011b, April 8). Life in 2100. The Week , 44–45.

Ker, T. (2011). Meet the new, old Otzi. Retrieved from http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2011/02/ pictures/110225-otzi-iceman-new-face-science-mummyoetzi/ .

Kurzweil, R. (2005). The singularity is near . New York, NY: Basic.

Kurzweil, R. (2012). How to create a mind . New York, NY: Viking.

Kurzweil, R. (2013). How my predictions are faring. Retrieved from http://www.kurzweilai.net/how-my-predictions-arefaring- an-update-by-ray-kurzweil .

Kurzweil, R., & Grossman, T. (2005). Fantastic voyage: Live long enough to live forever . New York, NY: Penguin.

Lore, P. (2012). The rise of nine . New York, NY: HarperCollins.

Magary, D. (2011). The postmortal . New York, NY: Penguin.

Malley, G. (2008). The declaration . New York, NY: Bloomsbury.

McAlpin, G. (2013). Stephen Mitchell on Gilgamesh . Retrieved from http://www.strippedbooks.com/comics/stripped03/ gilgamesh01.html .

Methuselah Foundation. (2012). Methuselah foundation website www.methuselahfoundation.org .

Mithen, S. (2005). The singing Neanderthals: The origins of music, language, mind, and body . London, England: Weidenfeld and Nicolson.

Murphy, S., Xu, J., & Kochanek, K. (2012, January 11). Deaths: Preliminary data for 2010. National Vital Statistics Reports 60 (4), 1–52.

Nelson, E., & Ciuffo, A. (Producers), & Herzog, W. (Director). (2010). Cave of forgotten dreams [Motion Picture]. United States: IFC Films.

Revis, B. (2011). Across the universe . New York, NY: Razorbill/ Penguin.

Roth, V. (2012). Insurgent . New York, NY: HarperCollins.

Rubalcaba, J., & Robertshaw, P. (2010). Every bone tells a story . Watertown, MA: Charlesbridge.

Shrestha, L. (2006). Life expectancy in the United States: CRS report for Congress . Washington, D. C.: Library of Congress

Strategies for Engineered Negligible Senescence. (2012). SENS website www.sens.org .

Sullivan, E. (2001). Some teens prefer the real thing: The case for young adult nonfiction. English Journal 90 (3), 43–47.

Thompson, N. (2013). Cave art the work of prehistoric preschoolers. Retrieved from http://www.cnn.com/2011/09/30/ world/europe/prehistoric-cave-art/index.html .

US Census Bureau. (2012). The 2012 statistical abstract . Washington, DC: US Census. Retrieved from http://www .census.gov/compendia/statab/cats/births_deaths_ marriages_divorces/life_expectancy.html .

United States Special Commission on Aging. (2013). Resources: Congressional research service reports . Retrieved from http://www.aging.senate.gov/crs/crs_aging_of_population .cfm .

Walther, M. P., & Fuhler, C. J. (2008). Pairing fiction and nonfiction. Book Links, 18 (2), 22–23.

Wang, M., & Holcombe, R. (2010). Adolescents’ perceptions of school environment, engagement, and academic achievement in middle school. American Educational Research Journal, 47 , 633–662.

Westerfeld, S. (2010). Uglies: Uglies, pretties, specials, extras . New York, NY: Simon Pulse.

Wilde, O. (2013). The picture of Dorian Grey . Retrieved from http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/174 .

World Health Organization. (2012). WHO database website www.who.int/healthinfo/statistics/mortality_life+tables/en/ index.html .


DLA Ejournal Home | ALAN Home | Table of Contents for this issue | Search ALAN and other ejournals